Please allow 48 hours for your delivery. We cannot accept next day deliveries as our schedule is usually full! Thank you!
WELCOME TO
CATHY'S COOKIE KITCHEN
Gift ideas for celebrations!
Anytime is a good time for our
award winning gourmet cookies!
Pre-order now for delivery on Valentine's Day, Friday, February 14th! Special occasions always sell out quickly so order now!
It's not too early!
Traditional Sugar Cookies with Buttercream Frosting are melt in your mouth delicious!
Click On any Photo
for Details & To Shop!
Or choose Traditional Sugar Cookies with Royal Icing. These taste as
good as they look!
Valentine Sprinkle Chocolate Chip!
Always a favorite!
Valentine m&m
Chocolate Chip!
Another favorite!
New! Our local
"Friday Half Dozen"!
See "Shop" page
for details!
12" More is More Valentine Cookie Cake! Chocolate chip, Sprinkles AND m&m's!
Our Celebration Tray!
Our Award Winners!
Perfect for Celebrations, our Award Winners include
Heath Bar Crunch, Milky Way Chocolate chip, S'mores, and our popular Crownie Bites!
There's something for everyone here: our delicious cookies, sugar cookie bites, caramel bars, and brownie bites! And it can be customized to your student's school colors!
Our Buttercream Sugar Cookies
are a popular Loft House,
soft sugar cookie with
lots of delicious buttercream frosting.
Click On Any
Photo To Shop!
Our Sugar Cookie Bars are unmatched!
A delicious sugar cookie dressed in our signature pink buttercream!
Our new mini triple layer cookie cake!
Our mini triple-layer
cookie cake filled with our
delicious buttercream.
We offer delicous Cookie Cakes in many sizes! 12 inches, 16 inches, double layer and an amazing triple layer! Our Cookie Cakes come in any of our cookie varieties!
We also bake delicious gluten free and vegan cookies that are sold throughout the
Syracuse area, as well as in our store!
See our Gluten Free and Vegan Page for details!
Our mini triple-layer
cookie cake in SU colors!
We specialize in deliveries to
Syracuse University
and love sending your love
to your students!
Our Celebration Tray in
SU colors!
You can choose shipping,
delivery or pick up at checkout!
Give us any additional info for your order in the"notes" section when you check out.
Please allow 48 hours when placing orders for delivery. All of our orders are baked fresh for your delivery! Thank you!
(eg, order Monday for Wednesday delivery and so on.)
Words of wisdom!
From the Cookie Monster himself!
Our store was a popular destination in Syracuse's Armory Square! Check out our amazing reviews on Google!
We are now a local online retail bakery, specializing in what we have always done best: delivering delicious cookie gifts to Syracuse University students; filling corporate and private orders; catering weddings, graduations, and parties; selling to our wholesale partners and basically baking the best local cookies in the Syracuse area!
​
We fill online orders,
Orders by text: 315-263-9363
and Orders by email - CathysCookieKitchen@gmail.com!
We still offer about 15 varieties or more of our delicious, award winning, gourmet cookies.
​
We are the only online bakery that is local and has served the Syracuse market
for the past 11 years!
​
Questions?
Call 315-263-9363
or email:
​
​
Our Instagram feed! Follow us on Instagram and Facebook
Photo: Cookie Monster Quote on our wall!
Check out some of our great reviews!
"My favorite cookie shop in Syracuse. They are award winning for a good reason. Cathy is one of the nicest people in the world and is always greeting you with a smile. I highly suggest stopping here when you get a chance."
​
"Easy to order, great communication, delivered right on time and best of all great reviews for the cookie cake. Will order again!"
"I ordered these cookies for a client of ours. Cathy was incredible. She responded to me right away. I live in Texas and after researching online, saw all the wonderful reviews. I knew we would be in good hands. She accommodated our unique order. I will definitely order from her again!"
"We live in NJ, but my son goes to Syracuse University. I started sending him cookie treats from Cathy last year during midterms and finals. However, I now signed him and his roommates up for the cookie of the month club. They all love it. Cathy is a delight to work with....she produces fabulous cookies and has a wonderful attitude. Plus, she also makes delicious gluten free cookies that I have had sent to NJ a few times. Give this fabulous cookie kitchen a try. Yum, yum!!!"